Environment Magazine September/October 2008

March 2007

Print
Email
ResizeResize Text: Original Large XLarge Untitled Document Subscribe

Where are the Sky's Limits? Lessons from Chicago's Cap-and-Trade Program

Economists have long argued that cap-and-trade programs are generally preferable to traditional approaches to regulating pollution. Traditional regulatory methods require regulators to identify which emission controls will be used by each facility, sometimes requiring a costly and time-consuming process for program administrators and the regulated industries. Furthermore, they typically do not take into account differences in the cost of controlling pollution across sources, so abatement does not always occur where it is most cost-effective to reduce pollution.

Cap-and-trade programs ensure that abatement occurs where pollution is least costly to control and places significant emphasis on the measurement of emissions and not on the actual method of control. These programs also provide incentives for regulated sources to reveal their actual cost of controlling pollution and adopt innovative technologies.

The watershed event that raised the popularity of cap-and-trade programs was the adoption and success of the national program to control sulfur dioxide (SO2) from coal-fired power plants in the United States. The SO2 program, which began in 1995, reduced emissions dramatically and at less cost than traditional methods.

Although there is a substantial literature on the U.S. SO2 and nitrogen oxide (NOx) cap-and-trade programs, little attention has been paid to a smaller, less publicized program: the Emissions Reduction Market System (ERMS) for volatile organic materials (VOMs) in Chicago, Illinois. 

The full text of this article is available by subscription only.

In this Issue

On this Topic

  • A Point of Departure in Muddy Waters Heated debates have continued for more than a decade over the extent to which international human rights law applies to the business world. A new UN report does much to provide a common point of departure. May/June 2009 (Abstract) 
  • Commentary - Giving Credit Where Credit Is Due January/February 2009 (Full) 
  • Editorial - A Sustainability Renaissance through the Depression The world’s economies have committed 10 percent of their collective wealth to address the current crisis and maintain the old order. But with the planet under much duress, we need a renaissance, not a restoration. May/June 2009 (Full) 
  • Editorial - Journeys toward Solutions Much more so than in decades past, the journey from environmental problem to solution now must traverse a zigzagged, often globe-trekking path. July/August 2009 (Full) 
  • Editors' Picks - July/August 2009 The UK Sustainable Development Commission's latest report questions our definition of prosperity. July/August 2009 (Full) 
  • Education for Sustainable Development Education at all levels can help move sustainable development beyond terminology and into practice, but the educational community has yet to embrace the broader concept as it has incorporated environmental stewardship. March/April 2009 (Abstract) 
  • Has Foreign Aid Been Greened? January/February 2009 (Full) 
  • Report on Reports - September/October 2009 Future Vision: What Lies Ahead? reviewed by Mohan Munasinghe. September/October 2009 (Abstract) 
  • The Great Salt Lake: America’s Aral Sea? With its main tributaries diverted for agricultural irrigation and production, the Aral Sea in central Asia lost 90 percent of its surface size with serious economic, environmental, and human health consequences. September/October 2009 (Abstract) 
  • The Humane Megacity: Transforming New York's Waterfront After being walled off in the nineteenth century, New York's waterfront is opening up for public use. This process offers insight on how to maneuver the conflicting views that often characterize creating a more humane place. July/August 2009 (Abstract) 

Taylor & Francis

© 2009 Taylor & Francis Group · 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 800, Philadelphia, PA · 19106 · heldref@taylorandfrancis.com